Weekly Feature

2017-02-15 / Editorial

Drug makers, doctors face Erie County lawsuit

Erie County Executive

Erie County has opened a new front in the fight against opioid abuse as we seek to use every possible tool we can to stem the tide of the epidemic that claimed more than 300 lives locally in 2016. Recently, I was joined by Erie County Attorney Michael Siragusa, as well as our commissioners of Health and Mental Health to announce that Erie County has filed a civil action against 11 pharmaceutical manufacturers and four doctors for their alleged roles in intensifying the epidemic through deceptive acts and practices, false advertising and fraud. In addition, these entities also profited handsomely as addiction rates and opioid-related fatalities rose across the county and the nation.

It is never an easy decision to enter into a lawsuit, especially against large and well-funded companies, but this step is necessary and will put these companies and individuals on notice that their allegedly predatory practices must stop. As the opioid epidemic has swept over Erie County, too many families have become familiar with the overpowering addiction these drugs cause, while many other people were prescribed opioid-related drugs for things such as common aches and pains. Also, many people received longer-term prescriptions than they should have, greatly increasing the likelihood of addiction. It was easy to be lulled into a false sense of security and safety about opioids, as the pharmaceutical manufacturers allegedly engaged in a long-term false advertising campaign to convince the public that they were safe, despite mounting evidence to the contrary.

Much like tobacco lawsuits exposed both the dangers of smoking and the duplicity of the tobacco industry, we believe this lawsuit will demonstrate that drug makers knew the danger of these drugs but sought to profit from them nonetheless. We believe the suit will show that the defendants misled patients and doctors about the appropriate uses, risks and safety of opioids, and that they knew opioids are too addictive and too debilitating for long-term use for chronic non-cancer pain, and that with prolonged use, the effectiveness of opioids wanes, requiring increases in doses to achieve pain relief and greatly increasing the risk of significant side effects and addiction.

Yet despite having this knowledge, the defendants allegedly worked to create a false perception of opioids’ safety in the minds of medical professionals and the public. While we cannot change the past, we can hold accountable those responsible for creating this terrible nationwide epidemic.

Return to top